TeamPhotoshop
Reviews, updates and in depth guides to your favourite mobile games - AppGamer.com
Forum Home Latest Posts Search Help Subscribe

TPS Challenge 2: Cyan vs. Eather (complete)

Home > Graphics and Photography Arena > Pixel Wars > Active Challenges...
Page: 1 2 Reply
Jan 27th 2002#28553 Report
Grums
Member since: Apr 4th 2001
Posts: 274
A hard one, but I vote for Eather.
Reply with Quote Reply
Jan 27th 2002#28556 Report
21knight
Member since: Jul 8th 2001
Posts: 180
eather

hmmmm....I vote for eather...close, jus seems like he took it a bit farther and gave the pic a while new theme.
Reply with Quote Reply
Jan 27th 2002#28574 Report
qtone
Member since: Nov 6th 2001
Posts: 240
cyan...

looks more realistic .... I agree with catscratch, Eather's image looks to chaotic ....
Reply with Quote Reply
Jan 27th 2002#28591 Report
Hunkorama417
Member since: Jun 30th 2001
Posts: 447
Eather

Cyan's wasn't manipulated very much, where as you can tell that Eather's was.
Reply with Quote Reply
Jan 27th 2002#28592 Report
tornupinside
Member since: Mar 27th 2001
Posts: 2237
For the same reasons andrew just posted, I just don't see much Manipulation to Cyan's version.... and it is the wrong size.

/me wonders why Matt thinks he isn't suppose to vote.
Reply with Quote Reply
Jan 27th 2002#28593 Report
x_fusiun_x
Member since: Sep 6th 2001
Posts: 3893
I agree cyans wasnt really manipulated that much but then eathers was manipulated but with just alot of filters...but i would have Eather on this one.....
Reply with Quote Reply
Jan 28th 2002#28607 Report
Biz_Maker
Member since: Oct 9th 2001
Posts: 426
Eather
Reply with Quote Reply
Jan 28th 2002#28641 Report
Member since: Jan 1st 1970
Posts:
Cyan


In my purely subjective oprinion: Eather went TOO far, Cyan didn't go far enough. I think the sky manip in Eather's put it over the edge--not recognizable. Cyan had a good start, but she didn't go all the way. the rollin' mist is nice, but the sky should be greyed out more to work, plus the image as a whole should be darker.

This is fun!
Reply with Quote Reply
Jan 29th 2002#28736 Report
deker
Member since: Mar 18th 2001
Posts: 6632
The 48 voting period is over, so.....

The winner is: Eather

By a vote of 9 to 5 in eather's favor.

Congratulations!
Reply with Quote Reply
Page: 1 2 Back to top
Please login or register above to post in this forum