Another new sig

Hi guys!

i know.. sigs sigs and sigs :D everybody asks

But plz take the time to tjeck out my new sig and tell me your oppenion..

should i replace the old???

BTW this is my first "grunge" effect looking thin EVER and i tried to make a sig with it any good?

<--The new one one

<-- The old one

i dont know i like em both. i like the new one but i think its a bit too big for what the design you put on it... and i like the old one because its fine and dandy =) sorry i couldnt decide

new one

It´s nice, the new one.

well okay.. ill wait and see what others might think...

too big?? to wide or to high??

Hmmm... the new one is cool, but I find myself liking the old one better. I think it's those *rivets* around the edges and the hole on the right that gives it character and almost make it look like an actual piece of metal. I like that.

But both are nice though.

txh the4man..

im glad that you think it looks like metal :D..

whats the "score" then?

New = 2½

Old = 1½

what no more?? plz i need more oppinions to make a decision.. is it really that ugly :( ?

i like the old one more