Sig check...

I got two options for a sig that I made myself, I know they're not all spiffy like everyone elses' is, but I wanna see what people think of my ameteur stuff and know which of the two I should pick (one of 'em might be a bit big though, but I'm not sure, thus I wanna see if anyone thinks its an alright size)...

A nice music one (I like music) I think about a good size for a sig...

A nice fantasy one (this is the one I'm not sure about size wise)

The second one has Tolkein elvish type in it, it actually translates into a cute story about a musical warrior or something, I forget, I made it a little while ago, I forget what I wrote for the story exactly...

Anyways, tell me what you think Thanks in advance :p .

Anybody?:(

I like the first one. Better colors....nice size...good composition...easy to look at. The second is too large...and it just has an empty feel. Like the entire sig is just based around that one character at the bottom..it feels like there is noting else.

Thanks for opinion , I'll use the music siggy then, at least until I can get a much cooler one;) (seems like maybe this is still a little large, or is it ok?)

i like the one u have, its nice colours and blending,
but the other one is to big to b a sig

I think you should take the second one and change it to the size and shape of mikeydude's (maybe a little taller). Put the character on the lower left, and the other thing on the upper right. Then have the same text wrapped in the same fashion. I think that would look good.

tom